How to Win in Today’s DTC Retail Landscape with a Multichannel Strategy—and Land a PE Exit

Your DTC engine’s humming—maybe a $75M apparel disruptor or a $150M footwear player—but growth’s stalling, and that 5-10% PE firms crave feels out of reach. A multichannel strategy isn’t just a pivot—it’s your growth rocket to expand customer reach, scale revenue, boost EBITDA, and snag a 5-7x exit worth $100M+. Let’s unpack the five steps to dominate today’s DTC landscape, with insights from Chubbies’ growth lifecycle, a real-world win, and a cautionary tale. Ready to win big? Let’s roll!

Why Multichannel Matters: Expand Reach, Win Customers, Secure Your PE Exit

DTC brands fish in the same digital pond—$50-$100 CAC (Forrester, 2023) on Meta ads, all chasing the same clicks. In the $400 billion apparel and footwear market (Statista, 2024), that’s a recipe for stagnation. Chubbies’ CMO nails it in their “Growth Lifecycle” infographic: DTC-only brands hit a wall—over-rotation on short-term tactics, channel overlap, cannibalization—losing TAM and profits. 

The fix? Expand customer reach through multichannel. Brick-and-mortar stores introduce your brand to new audiences who’d unlikely find you online, shifting acquisition costs to retailers. Social commerce grows 15% (McKinsey, 2024), wholesale 5%, but $50B in overstock (Coresight, 2024) and Trump’s 25% tariffs (February 2025) demand balance. For $50M-$200M consumer product brands, scaling $10M EBITDA to $20M isn’t just growth—it’s a $50M valuation jump at 5x, from $50M to $100M. Middle market PE firms pay 5-7x EBITDA (BizBuySell, 2023)—$10M nets $50M-$70M, $35M hits $175M-$245M—but they want reach. My deal thesis lives for this. Stay DTC-only, and you’re lucky to stay afloat; go multichannel, and you’re PE gold, 8x.

The 5-Step Multichannel Playbook: Expand Reach, Scale Smart

Here’s how to win by broadening your customer base—each step a PE valuation booster, inspired by Chubbies’ lifecycle stages:

1. Current State Analysis: Know Your DTC Limits
  • What It Is: Assess your DTC operation—revenue, CAC, brand strength. A $75M apparel brand might see $60M online, $10M EBITDA, but 1% brand awareness (Stage 1: “Everything is awesome, but I’ll never sell in AMZ or wholesale”).
  • Why It Wins: DTC-only brands hit a ceiling, missing TAM. High CAC and digital ad saturation shrink profits. New channels unlock $20M-$50M in new customers.
  • PE Upside: Sets growth stage—$10M EBITDA with $20M potential lifts $50M to $120M (6x). PE loves a roadmap.
2. Wholesale Channels: Tap New Audiences
  • What It Is: Partner with retailers—$100M DTC brand adds $30M via Nordstrom; $150M footwear brand gains $20M through Macy’s.
  • Why It Wins: “Add wholesale, overspend on Amazon”—shows retail exposes you to untapped buyers. Nordstrom shoppers aren’t your Instagram crowd—new reach, retailer absorbs CAC. Wholesale grows 5% (McKinsey, 2024).
  • PE Upside: Scales reach—$10M to $15M EBITDA, $50M to $90M (6x). My DTC multichannel thesis thrives here.
3. Amazon: Leverage Reach, Contain Risk
  • What It Is: Sell on Amazon—but cap it. A $75M apparel brand might add $10M via Amazon, keeping it below 20% of revenue.
  • Why It Wins: Amazon’s reach is massive—50% of U.S. e-commerce (Statista, 2024)—but Chubbies’ Stage 5 warns: overspending on Amazon kills profits. It’s a discovery tool, not your core. Balance avoids margin erosion and brand dilution.
  • PE Upside: Controlled growth—$15M to $18M EBITDA, $90M to $108M (6x). PE values discipline.
4. Social Commerce Channels: Ride the Digital Wave
  • What It Is: Sell via TikTok Shop, Instagram—$100M DTC brand pulls $15M from social; $50M footwear brand gains $10M.
  • Why It Wins:“DTC solid, right-sized Amazon spend”—highlights social’s 15% growth. It’s discovery for younger buyers, but not a profit driver—complements retail reach.
  • PE Upside: Momentum—$18M to $22M EBITDA, $108M to $132M (6x). PE loves modern scale.
5. Measuring Success: Balance for Profit
  • What It Is: Track KPIs—sales, margins, turns—across channels for a $75M brand; adjust if Amazon eats profits or wholesale lags.
  • Why It Wins:“All systems balanced”—stresses balanced channel distribution for profit. Too much wholesale or Amazon discounts hurt; 60% prefer seamless buys (Deloitte, 2024).
  • PE Upside: Predictability—$22M to $25M EBITDA, $132M to $150M (6x). PE buys steady growth.

Why Brick-and-Mortar Matters: The Live Show Your Customers Crave

Expanding reach isn’t just about revenue—it’s about meeting customer expectations. Think of your DTC brand like a band. Fans stream your music on Spotify, building a following, but soon they crave the live show—the full, immersive experience of seeing you perform. If you don’t play live, but rival bands do, you’ll lose credibility fast. Fans will buy tickets, merch, and downloads from competitors, shifting loyalty—what we call customer turnover in the consumer space. DTC brands face the same pressure: you can’t hide behind a website forever. Brick-and-mortar stores—whether directly owned or through wholesale partners like Nordstrom—put your brand on stage, letting new customers experience your product in person. A $75M apparel brand might gain $15M from Saks 5th Avenue shoppers who’d never scroll your Instagram. Retailers handle the CAC, you win the fans.

Real-World Win: Mack Weldon’s Multichannel Expansion

I’ve driven this—leading sales & strategy at Mack Weldon as a fractional executive, leading the sales team we launched a 3-pack underwear program into department stores and expanded the apparel collection into specialty stores, aligning the product roadmap with the business roadmap:

  • Current State: Digital CAC rising—limited reach.
  • Whitespace: Spotted $15M in department stores TAM—white space at $59 MSRP for a 3-pack, 10% above Calvin Klein and Ralph Lauren, premium yet accessible.
  • Wholesale: Launched at Bloomingdale’s, Saks 5th Avenue, Dillard’s. Completely new customer base with exclusive product, +86% growth. 
  • Measuring: Tracked sell-throughs, margins, store distribution for the soft launch, 10x growth potential with the all store roll out. 

 

Cautionary Tale: Allbirds vs. Nike Multichannel missteps

Allbirds, a digitally native footwear brand, soared with its Wool Runner sneaker—cult following, a few omnichannel stores, IPO rocket. But they delayed multichannel too long. CAC soared, omnichannel costs spiked, and profitability vanished—stock crashed from $29 to under $5 by March 2025, a 80%+ drop. Chubbies’ Stage 3—“Overlapping cannibalization”—nailed their flaw: DTC-only reliance left them exposed, and a late multichannel pivot gutted profits. Allbirds is my go-to warning of DTC-only dangers—and their Q4 2024 results (Retail Dive, March 12, 2025) hammer it home. Revenue tanked 22% to $55.9M, a $22M hit from closing 15 stores and a botched shift from DTC to wholesale/distributors. 

Contrast with Nike, a legacy giant. Overdistributed in wholesale, Nike foolishly cut third-party retailers such as DSW and Macy’s betting they could make up the difference by doubling down on DTC (nike.com, SNKRS app). But that strategy didn’t work either. They shrunk their customer reach who preferred brick & mortar shopping creating an out-of-sight, out-of-mind missed opportunity. Both the digitally native Allbirds and legacy giant Nike made a mistake on two opposite ends of the spectrum. 

Win Big, Exit Bigger

For $50M-$200M DTC consumer product brand—apparel disruptors, footwear champs—a multichannel strategy wins: analyze your state, leverage wholesale, contain Amazon, ride social commerce, measure sharp. Expand customer reach—stop fishing in the same digital pond. A $100M brand with $10M EBITDA surges to $20M—from $50M (5x) to $120M (6x)—$70M in your pocket. Flop like Allbirds, and you’re sunk.

PE’s circling—my investment thesis hits your scale. Don’t plateau at $10M EBITDA when $20M’s there. I’ll turn your DTC into a PE story they can’t resist. What’s your multichannel move?

Schedule Free Consultation